Key takeaways
- Count referring domains, not links: a site that mentions you in the footer of 500 pages is still one vote.
- A good link comes from a real site, read by people, on your topic, placed in the body of a page.
- Most "toxic" links can be left alone. Google says most sites do not need to disavow.
- Check that pages receiving links return a 200: a link to a 404 page is a wasted vote.
- The real deliverable of a backlink audit is the list of sites that cite your competitors but not you.
As of November 18, 2026, our own site, bloomwise.io, had 43 referring domains according to a backlink analysis tool. Of those 43, only two are real sites. The other 41 are spam domains with no authority at all, which showed up on their own since the summer. A raw report would have said "43 domains", and some dashboard might have produced an alarming toxicity score. The reality fits in one sentence: we have two real links, and all the work is ahead of us. That is exactly what a backlink audit should tell you about your own site. This article walks through the method, as a companion to our complete SEO audit guide, where links are only one of the dimensions.
What is a backlink audit?
A backlink audit is the inventory and triage of the links pointing to your site, to learn which ones count and which ones you are missing.
Backlinks are links from other sites to yours. To Google, each link from a trustworthy site is a form of recommendation, and one of the signals that separates two pages with comparable content. The audit answers three questions: who genuinely cites me, do those citations land on the right pages, and who cites my competitors without citing me.
Step 1: Collect your links
Start with the free source, then add a backlink analysis tool.
In Search Console, the Links report shows the top sites linking to you, your most linked pages and the anchor texts. It is Google's own view, but it is partial and says nothing about the quality of those sites.
A backlink analysis tool crawls the web on its own and gives you a more complete list, with an authority estimate for each domain, the date the link was found and its attribute (followed or nofollow). Numbers differ from one tool to the next, because each explores the web in its own way. That is fine: you are after a trend and site names, not an exact total.
Step 2: Count by domain, not by link
The number that matters is referring domains, meaning the distinct sites that cite you.
A partner who links to you from their footer creates one link per page on their site. With 500 pages, your tool shows 500 backlinks. To Google, it is still a single site recommending you, and a footer link weighs less than one placed in an article. Group your list by domain before any analysis. On most small sites, a list of several thousand links comes down to a few dozen domains.
Step 3: Judge the quality of each domain
A good link comes from a real site, read by real visitors, about your topic, citing you in the body of a page.
| Criterion | Good sign | Bad sign |
|---|---|---|
| The site | A publication, an association, an industry directory, a client, a partner | A random-looking domain with no readable content, in an unrelated foreign language |
| Traffic | The site shows up in Google for real queries | No visibility, no indexed pages |
| Topic | Close to your business or your area | Casino, pharmacy, loans, with no connection to you |
| Placement | In the text of an article or a listing | Footer, a list of 300 links, a catch-all "partners" page |
| Attribute | Followed, or nofollow from a recognized site | A sponsored link you paid for without realizing it |
Run each domain through this grid and sort it into three groups: useful, neutral, spam. On our own audit, the sorting was quick: two useful, 41 spam, none neutral.
Step 4: Look at the anchors
The anchor is the clickable text of the link, and its distribution tells you whether your link profile looks natural.
A natural profile is dominated by your brand name, your web address and generic phrases like "this site" or "learn more". A few anchors include your keyword, because people describe what you do. If half your links say exactly "cheap plumber Boston", though, that is a sign of manufactured links, and that is the kind of pattern Google classifies as link spam.
Step 5: Check the pages that receive links
A link only helps if it lands on a page that exists and matters to you.
List the pages on your site that receive links and check their status codes. A page that returns a 404 after a redesign wastes every link it had earned. The fix is simple: a 301 redirect to the equivalent page, as covered in our article on website migration SEO. Also look at the distribution: if every link points to your home page, your service pages and articles only benefit indirectly, through your internal linking.
Step 6: What to do about toxic links
In the vast majority of cases, nothing.
Google says it can assess which links to trust without additional guidance, and that most sites will not need the disavow tool. It only recommends disavowing if you have many artificial links that have caused a manual action, or are likely to, and only after trying to have them removed. It also warns that disavowing incorrectly can harm your site.
We have not disavowed our 41 spam domains. We never asked for them and none came from a purchase: that is precisely the case where Google says there is nothing to do. Spam links that show up on their own are everyday life for every site, and Google ignores them. Your time is far better spent on the next step.
Step 7: Compare with your competitors
The most useful part of the audit is the list of sites that cite several of your competitors but not you.
Take two or three competitors ranking ahead of you on your main queries and pull their referring domains. Cross the lists: an industry directory, a local publication or a trade association that cites two of your competitors has a good chance of citing you too. That list becomes your action plan: each row is a site to contact, a listing to create or a partnership to propose. For ways to earn those links without buying them, our article on quality backlink strategies covers what works.
With Bloomwise, backlink and competitor analysis is included in the subscription: you see who cites your competitors, and the assistant helps you sort the sites where a mention is realistic. Outreach stays human, and that is how it should be.
Mistakes that skew a backlink audit
Four habits come up often and give a false picture of your link profile.
Treating one tool's total as the truth. Two analysis tools never find the same links, and none of them sees everything Google sees. Always compare a single source over time: going from 20 to 30 domains in the same tool tells you something, while comparing one tool's 20 with another tool's 30 tells you nothing.
Disavowing as a precaution. This is the most expensive mistake, because it is invisible. A healthy link disavowed by mistake stops counting, and nothing tells you what you lost. Without a manual action in Search Console and without purchased links in your history, leave the disavow file alone.
Forgetting lost links. An audit looks not only at what is there, but at what has disappeared. If a partner rebuilt their site and your link was dropped, a polite message is often enough to get it back. Most analysis tools list lost links along with the date they vanished.
Ignoring unlinked mentions. A publication or a client that mentions your brand without linking to you is the easiest request you will ever make: they have already cited you, only the address is missing. Searching Google for your brand name in quotation marks brings these mentions up.
Do it yourself or hire someone?
For a site with fewer than a hundred referring domains, the audit takes half a day with Search Console and an analysis tool. Beyond that, or if you received a manual action for unnatural links, a specialist is worth it. Our article on SEO audit cost helps you judge a quote. And if you are running a technical SEO audit at the same time, start with that one: a site Google struggles to index will not benefit from its links.
Key takeaways
A backlink audit is not there to scare you with toxic links. It is there to tell you how many real sites recommend you, to check that their links land on live pages, and above all to find where the next ones will come from. Count by domain, judge each site on simple criteria, leave spam alone as Google recommends, and turn the competitor comparison into a list of sites to contact. At Bloomwise, we apply the same method to our own site every week. For what comes next, our guide to quality backlink strategies helps you move from audit to action.
Want to know where your site stands?
bloomwise audits your site in 2 minutes and gives you an SEO score with priorities to fix.
Get started